Dr Campbell has received the following awards:

Research Fellow at the Center for Advanced Internet Studies in Germany in 2020
Named Arts and Humanities Fellow from Texas A&M University in 2019
Presidential Impact Fellow from Texas A&M University in 2018
Harron Family Endowed Chair in Communication at Villanova University in 2018
Professional Excellence Award from Spring Arbor University Alumni Association in 2018
Clifford G. Christians Research Ethics Award from the Carl Couch Center for Social and Internet Research for her book Networked Theology in 2018
Scholar of the Year Award from the Religious Communication Association in 2017
Transformational Teaching Award from the Center for Teaching Excellence at Texas A&M University in 2017
Mentor of the Year Award from the Texas A&M Communication Graduate Student Association in 2014
Junior Scholars Award from the Southwest Commission on Religious Studies in 2006